Holy Tomato Too in Mullica Hill

It was a great place for my granddaughter's 5th birthday party, good pizza

We stopped after going to a haunted hayride. We scared up a huge appetite. The pizza was flavored with hints if garlic, basil and onion, the crushed tomatoes blends in nicely. It's a winner in our opinion. I definitely recommend stopping in. The staff is friendly and greeted us as we walked in. I was talking with the owners about the town and the restaurant. Overall great and friendly staff and the pizza smelled and tasted delicious and was worth the wait.

Best pizza I've ever had!

Loved it! Fabulous food and atmosphere!

Great pizza and marvelous help.

Had a family party for our sons Confirmation. Everyone was absolutely fantastic. it was like we were in our own house except all the food magically appeared. Highly recommend it!

Great pizza. Highly recommend the house salad. A little pricey and cash only.

Had the buffalo chicken pizza, super delicious

This place is worth trying. They have big portions for affordable prices. Constantly well kept and with great vibes. Highly recommended.

The Tomato on Main is the new name, and it's even better than before. We love going here. Delicious food and great service!

Delicious tomato pie. Crust is amazing. I don’t eat cheese but my family loved the cheese pizza. I don’t do reviews but I had to give this place a good review. Check it out & grab a piece of the heavenly sopapilla cheesecake.... best thing ever.

Cute place with the little town vintage feel. Food was really good especially the tomato soup. The pizza is thin crust with a sweet sauce. Good amount of options for types of gourmet pizza. Service was really good, everyone is friendly from the moment you walk in. Most importantly they serve wine from a local winery. All around good place to stop for a quick casual bite to eat.

Lots of inspirational decor to look at while waiting for delicious pizza.

The atmosphere was warm and friendly. The food was fantastic and the owners were so friendly. First time there but will definitely return!

Great atmosphere and ever better pizza! Perfect Friday night dinner spot

Nice decor, AMAZING pizza, great staff, delicious(but somewhat small) key lime pie

The pizza is excellent, thin crispy and huge!! The salad was fresh and delicious. We tried the cheesecake with the funny name (soup-something) and it was unbelievable. This place was a home run. Will definitely be back.

My friend and I accidentally ordered the wrong pizza, the owner was very nice and accommodating and the pizza was excellent !

The female boss is extremely rude and disrespectful to customers and staff. food is over priced and the workers are frequently yelled at by bosses infront of customers. a very unprofessional establishment. would recommend marino’s instead. it’s right down the road.

Made it to the final last Pizza - Trenton 🍅 Pie 🍕 location of the day.Many miles driving, 3 pies tasted and enjoyed.Made the mistake of asking for extra cheese on the "Flip". Crust not as crisp, flopped instead of staying flat and straight without a fold.Still very delicious, sauce tasted pretty good more liguid vs chunky as at the original Holy Tomato.They have also aligned themselves with NJ Winery.Villari Vineyards for a complete dining experience.

Great friendly staff. Feels like home and a very personable approach. A relaxing atmosphere. I wish them many years of success.

( This was my first time there with the new ownership.) Pizza was amazing, great side dishes as well. The service was above and beyond. The owners even came over to thank us. Very nice people. ( I'm actually thinking of having a family gathering there.) I was that impressed. 👍🏼🙂

Very nice location nice atmosphere and great service. Did a great job with respect to covid 19 guidelines.

This culinary experience was a cornucopia of hand crafted , old world flavors and recipes that made my mouth water in anticipation of the next Awesome dish Great job Tony & MA.

Amazing pizza and antipasto, best margherita pizza I’ve ever had. Staff was so nice and welcoming, even Abigail !

Great place!!

I been to both location pizza is always awesome, yesterday I went too Mullica hill location 3 times this summer, last 2 visits where not the same as used to be food took really long time both times, second visit we where not checked on very often sitting in the back, 3rd visit Are drinks came out and was apologized ice melted so are drinks where warm, when order was place it had to be rechecked 3 times it was right it was nothing big 2 plain pies and salad waiter said he had a brain fart, we never got are York mints last 2 visits they did mention last visit they ran out so I said it was ok juss didn’t get it last either so waiter made it point to find some which he either ignored or forgot after a few seconds. I will come back to holly tomato but only Blackwood location being I live in woodstown sorta sucks for the hike

Best Pizza in town. Stopped for the first time today and ate inside. Cute old school country feel and look. Super friendly staff and a good amount of pizzas to choose from. We chose the Parma and it was incredible. I was craving thin crust pizza and holy tomato did just that. The pizza was so thin it was almost unbelievable and half the time I was eating it I couldn't stop saying, "how did they get it this thin and this is the best pizza in the area". I look forward to many trips there, I'm sad it took me this long to try them out! I plan on trying one of their yummy homemade desserts next time too!

The staff is amazing and the pizza is the best I have ever had. I highly recommend the buffalo pizza and the barbecue pizza. The place itself is so unique and gives a great home atmosphere. This place is a must!

Amazing place for fantastic pizza, friendly staff, and warm atmosphere. We had a half white pizza and the other half tomato. The pizza is large but because it’s thin crust it’s easy to eat. If you’re on the interstate skip the horrendous food service stations and take the 6 minute trip to this gem of a place.